What the study found
The study found that, without information about economic contributions, support for deporting gay and straight unauthorized immigrants was similar. It also found that economic contributions substantially lowered support for deportation, but this effect differed by partisanship.
Why the authors say this matters
The authors conclude that these findings illustrate how partisan identity shapes the use of deservingness judgments in immigration attitudes. They also say the results have implications for immigration policy debates involving vulnerable immigrant populations.
What the researchers tested
The researchers used an original survey experiment with U.S. respondents, with the sample matched to Census quotas for key socio-demographic indicators. They examined how immigrants’ sexual identity and economic contributions shaped attitudes toward deportation, focusing on unauthorized LGBTQ+ immigrants in the United States and respondents’ partisanship.
What worked and what didn't
When no economic contribution information was provided, support for deporting gay and straight unauthorized immigrants was about the same. When economic contributions were mentioned, support for deportation fell for both groups. The partisan pattern differed: Democrats rewarded gay unauthorized immigrants significantly more than straight unauthorized immigrants for their economic contributions, while Republicans showed substantially lower support for deportation of straight unauthorized immigrants who had made economic contributions.
What to keep in mind
The abstract does not describe limitations beyond the study’s focus on U.S. respondents and unauthorized LGBTQ+ immigrants in the United States. No additional caveats are provided in the available summary.
Key points
- The study examined deportation attitudes toward unauthorized gay and straight immigrants.
- Without economic information, support for deportation was similar for gay and straight unauthorized immigrants.
- Economic contributions substantially reduced support for deportation for both groups.
- Partisan identity changed how respondents applied economic deservingness judgments.
- Democrats responded more favorably to gay than straight unauthorized immigrants with economic contributions, while Republicans responded more favorably to straight unauthorized immigrants with economic contributions.
Disclosure
- Research title:
- Economic contributions lower deportation support, with partisan differences
- Authors:
- Gabriele Magni, Zoila Ponce de León
- Institutions:
- Loyola Marymount University, University of Pittsburgh
- Publication date:
- 2026-03-12
- OpenAlex record:
- View
Get the weekly research newsletter
Stay current with peer-reviewed research without reading academic papers — one filtered digest, every Friday.